THIS CHANGES EVERYTHING

4 stars out of 5

Call me crazy, but I have zero problem with stories about characters who have psychic powers. But females with no common sense? Gimme a break. I was pretty much okay till about the 75% mark of this one; but at that point, the main character turned into one of those ditzy females who, while being chased by a monster wielding a carving knife, runs into the dark woods instead of the well-lit police station that’s half a block away. Spare me!

Ah, but other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how did you enjoy the play? Honestly, quite a lot. From start to finish, minus that annoying tidbit, I looked forward to my usual mid-evening reading session of at least an hour so I could find out how it ends as quickly as possible.

The story begins as Julia Pritzker, a U.S. transplant now living in Tuscany with her husband Gianluca Moretti  and their three-year-old daughter Leni. Julia, who is prone to “premonitions,” misses her best U.S. friend Courtney but hasn’t been in contact for at least a couple of years. Sort of on a whim, she places a call to her, only to get hit with a vision that something is about to go wrong. That hunch turned out to be deadly; Courtney answers the phone just as she’s entering her beloved grandmother Kay’s house to find she’s just been murdered. Needless to say, Courtney is in shock, and no surprise that she asks Julia to drop everything and come to her side. Julia’s husband isn’t thrilled that she’s leaving, but he also claims to understand her need to help her friend. He’s concerned, though, because history has shown when the two get together, they tend to get involved in things that can take a dark turn (apparently, there’s a previous book with both characters, which I haven’t read, but no matter because this one stands on its own quite well).

Of course, Julia’s plan to comfort Courtney and return home like the next day doesn’t come to fruition, much to the consternation of Julia’s husband and daughter, who believe their needs should come before those of a friend who hasn’t been in the picture for years (need I mention I totally agree)? But then it comes to light that Courtney’s aunt likely was killed because she’d found a “treasure” for her collection just the day before her death – and that might be a huge clue to why she was murdered. Not long thereafter, unsympathetic police pay a visit to Kay’s funeral – and (another surprise), arrest Courtney for her aunt’s murder. At that point, Julia reasons she can’t leave until she gets to the bottom of things.

Doing so takes some strange twists and turns, including a couple more inexplicable murders, war reenactment encampments and hints of domestic terrorists. None of those details, of course, will I provide – those are for other readers to learn for themselves. Overall, this is an entertaining, engaging book (as are the others I’ve read by this talented author), and I thank the publisher, via NetGalley, for the opportunity to read and review a pre-release copy.

This Changes Everything by Lisa Scottoline (Grand Central Publishing, July 2026); 400 pp.